Skip to main content

Table 1 A detailed description of the demographic characteristics, employment and field of professional activity divided by the knowledge on predatory journals

From: Awareness of predatory journals and open access publishing among orthopaedic and trauma surgeons – results from an online survey in Germany

 

All participants

N = 291

Knowledge of predatory journals

Yes

N = 116

No

N = 175

p-value

Sex, n (%)

 Male

231 (79,4)

95 (81,9)

136 (77,7)

0,768

 Female

54 (18,6)

19 (16,4)

35 (20,0)

 N / A

6 (2,0)

2 (1,7)

4 (2,3)

Age, years (± SD)

  < 30

14 (4,8)

8 (6,9)

6 (3,4)

0,558

 30–40

79 (27,1)

31 (26,7)

48 (27,4)

 41–50

67 (23,0)

26 (22,4)

41 (23,4)

 51–60

82 (28,2)

29 (25,0)

53 (30,3)

  > 60

49 (16,8)

22 (19,0)

27 (15,4)

Professional occupation, n (%)

 Student

8 (2,7)

6 (5,2)

2 (1,1)

0,018

 Resident

41 (14,1)

13 (11,2)

28 (16,0)

 Junior consultant

16 (5,5)

6 (5,2)

10 (5,7)

 Senior consultant

93 (32,0)

34 (29,3)

59 (33,7)

 Clinic director

63 (21,6)

27 (23,3)

36 (20,6)

 PPOTa

33 (11,3)

8 (6,9)

25 (14,3)

 Retired / Various

37 (12,7)

22 (19,6)

15 (8,6)

Passed promotion, n (%)

 Yes

243 (83,5)

103 (88,8)

140 (80,0)

0,048

 No

48 (16,5)

13 (11,2)

35 (20,0)

Passed habilitation, n (%)

 Yes

101 (34,7)

62 (53,4)

39 (22,3)

< 0,001

 No

190 (65,3)

54 (46,6)

136 (77,7)

Passed professorship, n (%)

 Yes

62 (21,3)

44 (37,9)

18 (10,3)

< 0,001

 No

229 (78,7)

72 (62,1)

157 (89,7)

Employer / Workplace, n (%)

 Basic and standard care hospital

51 (17,5)

7 (6,0)

44 (25,1)

< 0,001

 University Hospital

71 (24,4)

45 (38,8)

26 (14,9)

 Teaching hospital

95 (32,5)

31 (26,7)

63 (36,1)

 Rehab Clinic

8 (2,7)

4 (3,4)

4 (2,3)

 Private practice

31 (10,7)

10 (8,6)

21 (12,0)

 Research / Laboratory

18 (6,2)

15 (12,9)

3 (1,7)

 Various

18 (6,2)

4 (3,4)

14 (8,0)

Field of professional activity, n (%)

 Orthopaedics

60 (20,6)

29 (25,0)

31 (17,7)

0,163

 Trauma surgery

66 (22,7)

30 (25,9)

36 (20,6)

 Orthopaedics & trauma surgery

140 (48,1)

50 (43,1)

90 (51,4)

 Various

25 (8,6)

7 (6,0)

18 (10,3)

  1. aPPOT private practice-based orthopaedics and/or trauma surgeons