Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of the predicted anterior tibial translation and ACL strain at 13 s, when the drawer force reached the maximum, with the in-vivo and in-vitro experimental results for the intact knee joint. APFT = anterior-posterior femoral translation

From: Alteration in ACL loading after total and partial medial meniscectomy

 

Method

AP force  (AP moment)

Compression force

APFT

ACL strain  (%)

Present study

FEA

108 N (45Nm)

520 N

4.2 mm

5.5

Papageorgiou et al. [50]

Experimental

134 N

200 N

4.9 mm

―

Lin et al. [51]

Experimental

134 N

490 N

6.0 mm

―

Fleming et al. [52]

Experimental

(24Nm)

240 N

―

3.1

Asaeda et al. [53]

Experimental

146 N

732 N

4.2 mm

―

Rudy et al. [54]

Experimental

100 N

nil

5.4 mm

―